Create Your Own Pizza or Pick One of Our Favorites


When you explore the Papa Johns menu, you can see that it is vast. You can find sandwiches, wings, sides, and desserts. However, what stands out first and foremost is the pizza. Papa Johns has been known for its pizza since it opened. By using better ingredients, the pizza is top notch.

The only issue is that there are so many options, it can be hard to decide which pizza to order. You can always create your own, but there are also specialties that you cannot go wrong with.

Table of Contents

Epic Stuffed Crust

When searching for pizza deals near me, there is a good chance you will find one for the epic stuffed crust. This came around about four years ago, and it is one of the more popular crust options. In the original version, the handcrafted, original dough was filled with cheese and then baked for a gooey result.

This crust was in so much demand that Papa Johns expanded on the original. It went crazy and added pepperoni to the cheese, so now you can choose to have your crust stuffed with just cheese or also with pepperoni. You can order this crust with any pizza of your choosing.

The Works & Beyond

If you want someone else to do the pizza creating for you, you can choose from one of the pizzas on the menu. The Papa Picks include cheese, pepperoni, and sausage pizzas. However, the handcrafted specialties menu is where the fun begins.

Also Read:   The Best Pizza Options for Spice Enthusiasts: Hot and Spicy Pies

The works is basically a supreme, made with three meats and four veggies. If you like pineapple on your pizza, the super Hawaiian is a winner. Are you vegetarian and do not like red sauce? Try the fresh spinach and tomato alfredo pizza.

Additional specialty pizzas include fiery buffalo chicken, BBQ chicken and bacon, meatball pepperoni, Philly cheesesteak, Tuscan 6-cheese, garden veggie, the meats, and ultimate pepperoni. Any of these can be ordered on the crust of your choosing.

Create Your Own

Creating your own is not only a good time, but the options are practically endless. You start with one of the six crusts: original, stuffed, pepperoni stuffed, NY style, gluten free, and thin. Then you move on to the sauce options:

  • Traditional pizza
  • BBQ
  • Ranch
  • Alfredo
  • Buffalo
  • None

Next come the toppings. If you are a meat lover, there are many to select from. There are the traditional pizza toppings and then the less traditional, such as chicken, meatballs, bacon, anchovies, and Philly steak.

There are many veggie options. Popular ones include mushrooms, black olives, green peppers, and onions. Additional ones include pineapple, banana peppers, jalapeno peppers, spinach, and tomatoes.

You can create a gluten free pizza. You can even order a vegan pizza. Just make sure you leave off the cheese and meats.You can also create a crustless pizza. These pizza bowls, also known as Papa Bowls, contain all the ingredients of a pizza minus the dough. Choose from chicken alfredo, garden veggie, and Italian meats trio, or choose your own ingredients.